Finding the right tanning bed experience in NYC requires balancing your desired results with safety, convenience, and budget. This year, three products stand out: Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown offers a luxurious, hydrating boost to your sessions, ideal for those seeking a deep, long-lasting tan with a touch of skincare. The b.tan UV Tanning Bed Lotion provides an ultra-dark, fast-acting tan, perfect for UV veterans craving maximum darkness, though it might irritate sensitive skin. Meanwhile, That’s What Sea Said combines hydration with a tropical scent and a streak-free formula, making it an appealing choice for those prioritizing natural glow and skin health. Each has distinct tradeoffs, making your choice depend on your tanning goals and skin sensitivities.
Play games included with Prime
Start a Prime free trial and play with Amazon Luna on your devices.
Start playingAs an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown excels in hydration and long-lasting color, but may cause sensitivity and staining.
- b.tan UV lotion offers rapid, extreme darkness, suitable for experienced tanners, yet can be irritating for sensitive skin.
- That’s What Sea Said provides a natural, streak-free tan with hydrating ingredients, but might not suit those with fragrance sensitivities.
- All three products are designed specifically for indoor tanning beds, with varying focuses on skin health, darkness, and scent.
- Choosing between these depends on whether you prioritize deep results, skin nourishment, or natural appearance.
| Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown Indoor Tanning Bed Lotion Bronzer 10 Oz |  | Best Overall Hydrating Tanning Lotion | Size: 10 Oz | Formulation: Bronzer | Intended Use: Indoor tanning beds | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| b.tan UV Tanning Bed Lotion – Extreme Dark Tinted Tan Accelerator |  | Best for Rapid, Deep Tans | Intensifiers: x4000 | Made in: USA | Vegan: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| That’s What Sea Said Extreme Dark Tanning Bed Lotion Accelerator, 13.5 fl oz |  | Best for Natural, Hydrated Tans | Volume: 13.5 fl oz | Type: Dark Tanning Bed Lotion Accelerator | Features: Tattoo-friendly, Cruelty-free, Hydrating, Streak-free | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown Indoor Tanning Bed Lotion Bronzer 10 Oz
Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown stands out for its luxurious, nourishing formula that supports deep, even, and long-lasting tans. Unlike many bronzers that focus solely on color, this lotion emphasizes skin health, with it ultra-hydrating and supporting skin elasticity. Its creamy texture enhances tanning sessions, leaving a pleasant fragrance that elevates the experience. Compared with the b.tan lotion, it may not produce the quickest or darkest results, but it appeals to users seeking a balanced blend of color, skin care, and comfort. Its primary tradeoff is that it can cause skin sensitivity for some users and might stain clothing or bedding if not carefully applied.
Pros:- Provides deep, even, and long-lasting tan
- Ultra-hydrating and nourishing for skin
- Pleasant fragrance enhances tanning experience
- Supports skin firmness and elasticity
Cons:- May cause skin sensitivity for some users
- Contains bronzers that could stain clothing or bedding
Best for: Those who want a deep, lasting tan with added skin nourishment and a spa-like scent.
Not ideal for: Tanners seeking the darkest possible bronze or those with sensitive, easily irritated skin.
- Size:10 Oz
- Formulation:Bronzer
- Intended Use:Indoor tanning beds
Our verdict“A versatile choice for users prioritizing skin health and a natural, enduring glow.”
b.tan UV Tanning Bed Lotion – Extreme Dark Tinted Tan Accelerator
b.tan UV Tanning Bed Lotion is designed for tanners who want to achieve maximum darkness quickly. Its formula is boosted with intensifiers that increase melanin production by up to 4000 times, making it perfect for experienced users who want an ultra-dark bronze in fewer sessions. Enriched with peptides and moisturizing ingredients, it supports skin health despite its intense tanning focus. However, because of its potency, it can cause irritation for sensitive skin types, and its strong scent may be off-putting for some. This lotion is specifically formulated for UV beds, so it’s not suitable for spray or lotion-only tanning.
Pros:- Provides an extremely dark tan quickly
- Contains skin-boosting peptides and moisturizing ingredients
- Vegan and cruelty-free formulation
- Enhanced melanin production for faster results
Cons:- May cause skin irritation for sensitive skin
- Designed specifically for UV tanning beds, not for lotions or sprays
- Potentially strong scent due to tanning ingredients
Best for: Experienced tanners aiming for the deepest, fastest results in NYC’s indoor beds.
Not ideal for: Beginners or sensitive skin users who need gentler formulations or are prone to irritation.
- Intensifiers:x4000
- Made in:USA
- Vegan:Yes
- Cruelty-Free:Yes
Our verdict“Best suited for seasoned tanners wanting rapid, maximum darkness with the understanding of possible skin sensitivity.”
That’s What Sea Said Extreme Dark Tanning Bed Lotion Accelerator, 13.5 fl oz
That’s What Sea Said combines hydration and natural ingredients to accelerate dark tanning without streaks or orange tones, making it ideal for users who want a rich bronze with minimal fuss. Its formula contains aloe vera, coconut, and passionfruit, which hydrate the skin and help prevent streaks and stains. The fragrance is light and tropical, adding to its appeal for those who prefer a fresh scent. Unlike the other two, this lotion is tattoo-friendly and cruelty-free, making it suitable for a broader range of skin types and preferences. However, it might not deliver the same rapid or ultra-dark results as the b.tan lotion and may be less effective for users with very resistant skin.
Pros:- Accelerates dark tanning for a deeper bronze quickly
- Hydrating and non-sticky with natural ingredients
- No streaks, stains, or orange tones on skin or clothes
- Tattoo-friendly and cruelty-free
Cons:- May not be suitable for sensitive skin
- Contains fragrance which could cause irritation for some users
Best for: Those seeking a natural, streak-free, deeply hydrated tan with a tropical scent.
Not ideal for: Tanners who want the darkest possible bronze or have fragrance sensitivities.
- Volume:13.5 fl oz
- Type:Dark Tanning Bed Lotion Accelerator
- Features:Tattoo-friendly, Cruelty-free, Hydrating, Streak-free
Our verdict“A balanced option for users who prioritize skin health and natural-looking results over ultra-dark tanning speed.”
How We Picked
In selecting these products, I prioritized their relevance to NYC tanning bed users, focusing on their core benefits, formulation quality, and user safety. I considered their versatility for indoor use, ratings for skin compatibility, and how well they complement different skin types and tanning goals. Products were compared for their ability to deliver fast, deep tans versus more natural results, with attention to potential drawbacks like irritation or staining. Cost-effectiveness and formulation transparency also played a role, ensuring these picks serve a diverse range of NYC tanners.
Factors to Consider When Choosing Tanning Beds Nyc
Choosing the right tanning lotion for NYC indoor beds depends largely on your tanning goals—whether you want rapid darkness, skin nourishment, or a natural glow. Understanding key factors like formulation, ingredients, and compatibility helps ensure you select a product that enhances your results without compromising skin health. Below, I break down what to look for and how each product aligns with different tanning preferences.
What to Consider When Choosing a Tanning Lotion for NYC Beds
First, determine whether your priority is achieving the deepest, quickest tan or maintaining skin hydration and health. If speed and darkness are your goals, products like b.tan UV are designed for maximum melanin production, but they may cause irritation. For those seeking a more balanced, long-lasting tan with skin benefits, Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown offers hydration and nourishment, though it may take longer to develop. Natural ingredients and fragrance-free options like That’s What Sea Said cater to sensitive skin and those who prefer a more subtle, streak-free bronze. Compatibility with your skin type, the presence of skin-boosting ingredients, and potential sensitivities should guide your choice.
How to Maximize Results and Minimize Risks
Always perform a patch test before applying any new lotion extensively, especially if you have sensitive skin. Follow the instructions carefully, and consider your skin’s response to bronzers and accelerators. Hydrating formulas can support skin elasticity and comfort during tanning, but overuse of rapid darkening products might lead to irritation or uneven results. For best results, combine proper preparation with consistent application, and avoid overexposure to UV rays to protect your skin’s health.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use these tanning lotions outside of NYC tanning beds?
These products are specifically formulated for indoor UV tanning beds, so their effectiveness and safety are optimized for such environments. Using them outside in natural sunlight or with spray tanning methods might not produce the expected results and could even cause skin irritation or uneven tanning. Always check the manufacturer’s instructions to ensure safe and effective use within their intended setting.
Are these lotions safe for sensitive skin?
While some formulations like That’s What Sea Said are designed to be gentle and fragrance-free, others like b.tan UV contain potent accelerators that might irritate sensitive skin. It’s advisable to perform a patch test before full application, especially if you have known sensitivities. If you have very sensitive or reactive skin, opt for products with natural ingredients and minimal additives.
How long does it typically take to see results with these lotions?
The time to see noticeable tanning results varies based on the product and your skin type. The b.tan UV lotion is designed for rapid, intense darkness, often producing visible results after a single session. Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown may take longer to develop a deep, lasting tan but provides a nourishing experience along the way. That’s What Sea Said offers a natural, streak-free glow that generally builds over several sessions, especially if used consistently.
Can I combine these lotions with other tanning products?
It’s generally best to use each lotion as directed without mixing different formulas, as combining products can interfere with their effectiveness and increase the risk of skin irritation. However, you can alternate products based on your goals—for example, using a hydrating lotion for maintenance and a dark accelerator when you want a quick, deep tan. Always check ingredient compatibility and avoid overloading your skin with multiple products at once.
Do these products stain clothing or bedding?
Some bronzer-containing lotions, like Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown, may stain clothing or bedding if not fully absorbed or rinsed off properly. The other two products—b.tan and That’s What Sea Said—are formulated to minimize staining, with the latter explicitly boasting a streak-free, stain-free finish. To avoid unwanted marks, allow the lotion to fully dry before dressing and wash bedding regularly if used frequently.
Conclusion
For NYC residents who prioritize a deep, long-lasting tan and are comfortable with skincare and potential staining, Ed Hardy Butter Me Brown offers a nourishing, balanced approach. Those seeking rapid, ultra-dark results and are experienced with UV tanning should consider b.tan UV, but be mindful of skin sensitivities. If a natural, streak-free bronze with hydration and fragrance considerations is your goal, That’s What Sea Said makes a compelling choice. Your decision should align with your desired results, skin type, and tanning experience preferences.
Fall yard work Picks
leaf blowers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
